But then you're back with the concern mentioned above. Do you have a suggestion to fix the issue?
Printable View
Every squirrel deserves a nut at some point in their lives right?
But what about non-squirrels? :(
I meant to imply the following : the result is a potentially huge advantage for something that is due to purely accidental (not random, but it has the same effect) situations.
Can't ppl just roleclaim? If someone lies one person will in most cases know then
Also wifom if you're scum and not sure whether it's safe to fake a role or not in later stages
I think it'd be better to just not allow any roles that have conditions to them which would give the creator an advantage.
Stealth already put in the rules that revealing which role you created is forbidden, so even if you get in the final 3 and didn't see your role flip you'd never know who of the other 2 faked their claim.
For example stuff like person to hammer this guy dies, etc
The issue I see with your idea, unless I misunderstand it, is that it restricts rolecard freedom by a lot, which is probably the greatest sin possible in a "bring your own role" setup.
We could have all roles in the Role Compendium, and any combination of these roles (host balanced, obviously) as a possibility. It would cover all issues, I believe.
It's a very minor restriction really. You can just add the word random to any effect you wanna add and it'd almost always solve any potential issues.
Adding filler roles and at the same time removing handmade roles with pictures made by the players is an incredibly bigger degradation to the games quality imo.
Here’s my decision. Will update the setup to reflect this later.
1. On a player’s death, their rolecard will be fully revealed.
2. In addition, the rolecard that the dead player submitted will also be fully revealed, but not who has it.
3. Once 40-50% of the players are dead, they may vote to decide to release the remaining roles to the public. Amongst the released roles will be some random bullshit roles which I have made, which are not in the setup. This is to prevent a mass claim scenario.
setup has been updated accordingly @Marshmallow Marshall
lets do this
I thought I had already posted it, but apparently I didn't... It's probably my poor internet again, sorry.
As always, this kind of setup is not suitable for any Ladder season, and should not be seen as overly serious (while the FM Rules still apply). Under these conditions, the setup seems enjoyable, so it is Approved.
You may post signups when Magoroth's game, The Agency : Chapter I, will be finished.
If anyone would like to host this again, be my guest. Otherwise I would like to submit this to host after Bio-Med finishes.