Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
If MM is scum, then basically the other scum are the lurkers, I think?
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
If both MM and Magoroth were scum, unless one was neut, then we're in a world where the other scum just afked while their teammates were getting SvS lynched, and then they're basically non-factors today as well
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Ultra simplified PoE for me:
Magoroth(Dead)
*Wiisp(Dead)
Frinckles
Naz
Kovath
The Lawyer
--------------------------------
Naz, Varcron, The Lawyer, Kovath are all clear for hammering Mag. And obviously I'm clearing myself.
Gyrlander
Stealthbomber16
Varcron
Efekannn02
--------------------------------
Gylander, SB16, Varcron are all people I'd like to townread. Efe is still null.
Light_Yagami
MarshmallowMarshall
--------------------------------
Light / MM had the most suspicious contact with Magoroth imo. And for what it's worth, Light's reluctance to jump on an MM wagon could be telling.
*We technically don't know if Wiisp was town yet.
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kovath
If both MM and Magoroth were scum, unless one was neut, then we're in a world where the other scum just afked while their teammates were getting SvS lynched, and then they're basically non-factors today as well
I think that's possible.
At any rate, the only thing I'm concerned about is if MM and Mag were scum together, Mag was trying to bus the hell out of MM.
Which is ironic, MM was trying to buddy the hell out of Mag.
I'm just not sure if I can see him doing that, but I also couldn't see him not being tailored until so long ago.
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
I wonder if there is a town perspective where Mag was actually soldier and just dumped that in his LW for some reason. Maybe he wanted to pretend a TPR died? idk
I think Wiisp is mechanically town for dying to the German kill but I don't think it's super important for today
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kovath
I wonder if there is a town perspective where Mag was actually soldier and just dumped that in his LW for some reason. Maybe he wanted to pretend a TPR died? idk
I think Wiisp is mechanically town for dying to the German kill but I don't think it's super important for today
Possibly? The one I offered assumed he was tailored.
Which we now know that he was 100% scum.
If he were town this game lying wouldn't do anything beneficial to help. Scum has a death cop.
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
@naz
your case on MM is pretty good.
At this point I feel like I'm just slowrolling a vote for Huey. I dislike slowrolling though. And I've given MM plenty of time to chime in.
-vote Marshmallow Marshall
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
So, your point makes sense in general. Though, looking closely at the OoO
-Both- coroners go -after- the tailor. If Magoroth was tailored, then no one knows his real role - I could potentially see the world where Magoroth knew this and fake-claimed just in case he was tailored? It's really far-fetched though
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kovath
So, your point makes sense in general. Though, looking closely at the OoO
-Both- coroners go -after- the tailor. If Magoroth was tailored, then no one knows his real role - I could potentially see the world where Magoroth knew this and fake-claimed just in case he was tailored? It's really far-fetched though
A good thing to point out is that if he didnt claim section d raider, I would still be under the assumption that he was tailored. Seems like a misplay on his part, I'm sure he was getting a kick out of me going on and on.
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
No one mentioned the possible mechanical implications of claiming it though until I noticed it earlier in the setup, though
It's possible he didn't know about it
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
Ultra simplified PoE for me:
Magoroth(Dead)
*Wiisp(Dead)
Frinckles
Naz
Kovath
The Lawyer
--------------------------------
Naz, Varcron, The Lawyer, Kovath are all clear for hammering Mag. And obviously I'm clearing myself.
Gyrlander
Stealthbomber16
Varcron
Efekannn02
--------------------------------
Gylander, SB16, Varcron are all people I'd like to townread. Efe is still null.
Light_Yagami
MarshmallowMarshall
--------------------------------
Light / MM had the most suspicious contact with Magoroth imo. And for what it's worth, Light's reluctance to jump on an MM wagon could be telling.
*We technically don't know if Wiisp was town yet.
Seriously?
-vote Marshmallow Marshall
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kovath
If both MM and Magoroth were scum, unless one was neut, then we're in a world where the other scum just afked while their teammates were getting SvS lynched, and then they're basically non-factors today as well
I think light is the neutral
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
like these reactions SCREAM that he was tailored.
im not crazy here tbh
so 4 people knew he was tailored? My goodness, the host must have given us the wrong setup then.
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
The Lawyer
Sheeping a lynch on Mag? I gave my reasoning about why I voted Magoroth. Because he was shading Light for the "scum slip" and then unvoted him. Go read the thread. Seriously.
Also I haven't voted MM. Yet.
Does that theory imply that Light is scum?
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Gyrlander
so 4 people knew he was tailored? My goodness, the host must have given us the wrong setup then.
I like the banter, but until 2 hours ago it was completely plausible.
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
L-1 gyr hammer?
Vote Count
Marshmallow Marshall (5 [L-1]):
Frinckles, Light_Yagami, Efekannn02, naz, Stealthbomber16
Kovath (1 [L-5]):
Varcron
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kovath
What are you talking about? Magoroths bio flipped at eod1 with his name
Welp, I guess Kovath becomes the strongest townread due to making clear that Mag is basically Mafia and fucked up.
I'll check something just to confirm, however.
@Huey The Long
Section D doesn't get a Bio, but does he have one that he isn't aware of? If he dies, a Bio isn't posted and that's the end of it?
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Oh before you hammer, thoughts on Mafia target tonight?
Re: S-FM Fractured Whizzbang (12P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
naz
L-1 gyr hammer?
Vote Count
Marshmallow Marshall (5 [L-1]):
Frinckles, Light_Yagami, Efekannn02, naz, Stealthbomber16
Kovath (1 [L-5]):
Varcron
What's the point? If it's plurality we can use this extra time my dear.