PDA

View Full Version : GF vs Arsonist?



aefi
May 3rd, 2011, 01:35 PM
fist thing first..
why is it so unfriendly to register here? when i was entering my email/name/password the field for it went blank so i couldnt see anything and just had to guess..

2. why there is weird options for victory?
one game i was gf and there was me and arsonist left. i was immune to be killed at night but arsonist wasnt. and game said that he won.
another game it was me as GF and Serial killer left. he won. however it supposed to be tie cuz none of us could die, or be lynched.
why roles that said "be the last alive" as option for victory is won when there actually 2 persons left.?

Afumba
May 3rd, 2011, 02:21 PM
I had the same thing^^ with SK as GF...
But honestly said... i dont mind... if an SK or Arsonist... manages to stay alive... beeing last together with GF... SK/Arso deserves the win. They have a hard time to win anyway... so giving making the neutral killer win when tied with mafia... is fine in my eyes.

I have a second question tho... if 1 SK, 1 GF and 1 Escort are left... (Escort can be any other citizen) GF and SK have night immunity... Does Town win if no one kills the Escort?
Sk wins if Escort dies... so GF obviously dont want to kill her... and Escort blocks SK... so its a stalemate... and Town will win?
Had a similiar thing thats y i am asking...

Dark.Revenant
May 3rd, 2011, 02:21 PM
1. I couldn't find the part of the CSS that corresponds to that particular box.

2. I have explained before that extremely complicated victory conditions like these (they seem simple, but they are really NOT) would take far too much development time to do. Also, I don't believe in ties; arsonists and sks would tie half the games they would have won. So instead they win "ties".

Also, town loses all ties.

Fat Tony
May 3rd, 2011, 05:57 PM
It's pretty hard to win as Arson or SK. A lotta luck has gotten you to the end, even more so with Arson (imo Arson needs more protection, he is just too damn easy to find).

Clawtrocity
May 3rd, 2011, 06:06 PM
There's an option for the sheriff to not be able to detect arson and you don't NEED investigators in the game. You determine how strong and how weak someone is usually just by the settings of a game.

Elixir
May 5th, 2011, 01:10 AM
All cases the on their own neutrals beat the teams. And the SK beats the arson in that 1 on 1. I think its fine like that.