Anti-Role!

[Voss]

I propose that we add an 'anti-role' section to each of the sections, where applicable. For example, when playing against a Jailor, and you do not want to be executed, you do this, and this. etc.

Does this make sense?

[Damus_Graves]

It does make sense.

I can support this

[Deantwo]

you mean a section on each role's page that explain common strategies to combat the given role...

mmh i guess it could be good... but we would suddenly have a lot of the same hints written on many pages... so if something about it change it'll be hell to fix... but yeah ^^;

just need something nice to call the section i guess... and would the section be needed for all roles?

[Damus_Graves]

Defense Strategies?

[Voss]

"Playing against?" and what kind of things would be repetitive?

Cuz there are a lot of tips that new mafia players could get from wiki, but I don't know where to put it.

[Deantwo]

(i wrote a nice reply to this last night on my smart-phone... why isn't it here? T_T)


Defense Strategies?

not sure i like the idea of a "Defense Strategies" section right after a "Strategies" section...


"Playing against?" and what kind of things would be repetitive?

Cuz there are a lot of tips that new mafia players could get from wiki, but I don't know where to put it.

making this section... it would in the end end up with a lot of the same information as there is in the "Strategies" section for each role... and having the same information multiple places can be annoying when one of the said things changes...

maybe we should just start updating the False Claiming Strategy (http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/False_Claiming) and other
Strategy (http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/Category:Strategies) pages?

[Damus_Graves]

You could add it to the Strategy page.
You don't want to give up to much though. Players need to think for themselves too.

[Voss]

(i wrote a nice reply to this last night on my smart-phone... why isn't it here? T_T)



not sure i like the idea of a "Defense Strategies" section right after a "Strategies" section...



making this section... it would in the end end up with a lot of the same information as there is in the "Strategies" section for each role... and having the same information multiple places can be annoying when one of the said things changes...

maybe we should just start updating the False Claiming Strategy (http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/False_Claiming) and other
Strategy (http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/Category:Strategies) pages?

False claiming is different to what I'm proposing. Its specifically countering each role, when possible, things to account for when playing with them. Another good example comes to mind with disguiser, and leaving a code. That wouldn't go with false claiming, would it?

and i'll start updating the false claiming sight too i guess =D

[Damus_Graves]

False claiming is different to what I'm proposing. Its specifically countering each role, when possible, things to account for when playing with them. Another good example comes to mind with disguiser, and leaving a code. That wouldn't go with false claiming, would it?

and i'll start updating the false claiming sight too i guess =D

That actually seems like it would be a small section. There isn't much to counter when your talking about vigilantes or jailors

[Voss]

That actually seems like it would be a small section. There isn't much to counter when your talking about vigilantes or jailors

well i dont know about vigilante yet, but yeah this wouldn't go under strategies, it would go under the role wiki page.

there are TONS of stuff you could claim to jailor if you're evil, especially SK.

[Deantwo]

well i dont know about vigilante yet, but yeah this wouldn't go under strategies, it would go under the role wiki page.

there are TONS of stuff you could claim to jailor if you're evil, especially SK.

could just make some new Strategy (http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/Category:Strategies) pages or look at the others ^^;

most of the strategies you'd write on the suggested section would be very depended on what role you are... so writing it on the given role would be better...

[Voss]

could just make some new Strategy (http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/Category:Strategies) pages or look at the others ^^;

most of the strategies you'd write on the suggested section would be very depended on what role you are... so writing it on the given role would be better...

this.

[Voss]

so name of it is...

[Deantwo]

could just make some new Strategy (http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/Category:Strategies) pages or look at the others ^^;

most of the strategies you'd write on the suggested section would be very depended on what role you are... so writing it on the given role would be better...

this.

i meant writing for exsample on GF's page that he shouldn't tell a Jailor that he is Citizen

writting that on the Jailor's page would only confuse people

[Voss]

'Counter Strategies!"

that could work

[Deantwo]

'Counter Strategies!"

that could work

read what i said? ^^;


i meant writing for exsample on GF's page that he shouldn't tell a Jailor that he is Citizen

writting that on the Jailor's page would only confuse people

[Voss]

read what i said? ^^;

thats a godfather tactic, not an anti-jailor tactic?

[Deantwo]

thats a godfather tactic, not an anti-jailor tactic?

yeah... but i mean that it'd be less confusing if you just write on each of the roles's own pages that'd need to know how to 'counter' a Jailor...

or make a Strategy (http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/Category:Strategies) page about how to counter Jailors (and other roles)

there is such a thing as adding to much information to a page

[Voss]

yeah, but look at it this way, if you're playing mafia, and you have a quick question or need help, they go to that page.

and i don't know how well you can organize an Anti-Role Strategy page. It'd just be filled with information that I think belongs on each specific role page.

[Deantwo]

yeah, but look at it this way, if you're playing mafia, and you have a quick question or need help, they go to that page.

and i don't know how well you can organize an Anti-Role Strategy page. It'd just be filled with information that I think belongs on each specific role page.

like Damus_Graves said... maybe just let people think for them selves ^^;

[Voss]

It does make sense.

I can support this

he supports this LOL =(

[Voss]

i just need a name for it, and i'll start implementing it.

[Damus_Graves]

i just need a name for it, and i'll start implementing it.

Defense Strategies!

or

Fake Claims

i dunno which